UPDATED: The Mighty Shoe Dilemma

UPDATED: Added more input from Ryan in February 2017.

Almost anyone who has had an ExoSym will readily tell you, finding the right pair of shoes is a long and sometimes financially agonizing process. Anyone with painful degenerative foot problems will laugh through their tears while wisecracking “tell me something I don’t know.”

I’ve been on the search for the perfect comfy shoes for close to 20 years. As my feet hurt and further degenerate, this perfect shoe became more and more elusive. In all that time, I didn’t find one person – doctor, podiatrist, shoe sales person – anyone who could tell me what I needed to look for in a perfect shoe. Until now.

This past weekend, I took a trip to Wide Shoes Only in Renton. There I met Dominic, the shoe angel. The son of cobblers who has inherited the store and now runs it as president, Dominic not only knows shoes, he knows foot issues and what shoes are best for your situation. And he knows the ExoSym as well as other AFOs.

In fifteen minutes he’d educated me on what my weak, unstable club feet need and what the ExoSym requires to perform at full potential. He then showed me how to look for those things in every shoe I considered.

Stability

Dominic told me the ExoSym, and other AFOs, require a stable shoe. That means it is stiff in the bottom, not squishy to allow rolling right or left. The ExoSym doesn’t allow for the ankle to roll, so a shoe that does that will throw you off balance and be “like walking on a soft mattress,” Dominic said.

SquishyShoe
See how I can squish it with my fingers? Not good for ExoSym.

For example, New Balance has a number of shoes with roll bar technology as well as newer technology, not allowing the heal to roll in either direction. The shoes the Hanger Clinic gives out with ExoSyms (New Balance 1540) includes this technology.

RollBarTech
Roll bar technology.

When I shared this information with Ryan Blanck, creator of the ExoSym, he agreed to a point. However, the design of the ExoSym, unlike other AFOs, he said could handle a little squish in the sole. He suggested trying to twist the shoe in your hands (one hand on the toe and one on the heal and turning your hands in opposite directions). If it twists easily, don’t buy it. He said look for a solid sole (not the new trendy style of flexible soles pictured below).

skechers-sneaker
These shoes have the worst kind of soles for your ExoSym. Avoid these types of sectioned soles.

Both Ryan and Dominic agree that you need a stiff forward part of the sole. A shoe that doesn’t bend so easily at the ball of the foot will provide more stability as your foot doesn’t bend at all in the ExoSym.

Width

Shoes come in all kinds of verbiage for width – wide, extra wide, extra extra wide, 2E, 4E, 6E, W, WW, etc. Generally, these are determined from the base of the heal up to the ankle. Imagine the letter V with the point at the bottom gone. The wider the V shape between the sides of the heel and the top of the shoe is used to determine width. It’s not simply horizontal width, Dominic explained. Every shoe manufacturer has their preferred width measurement and quite honestly, said Dominic, the width designation doesn’t matter anywhere near as much as the “last.”

Last

Drawn from the old cobbler word for the “last block,” or the block of wood that was whittled from drawings of a customer’s foot then used to design the shoe around, today’s “last” is the volume inside a shoe.

WideShoePhilos
This is on the wall in two places at Wide Shoes Only.

An extra extra wide in one shoe, for instance, doesn’t have as much volume as an extra wide in another shoe.

TwoShoes
The one on the left is a W while the one on the right is a WW. Yet, clearly, the one on the left is physically wider. Beware of only looking at width designation. Look at the last. (Neither of these shoes work with the ExoSym, however…)

I discovered for me I needed more last, in terms of physical width for my wide foot plus the ExoSym, but also the cone (top of the foot) needs to be higher than typical or the pressure down on my foot causes my toes to fall asleep. This is what the New Balance 1540s I got from the clinic were doing – too tight and putting my toes to sleep.

With Dominic I found three amazing shoes. A (sadly, this is the story of my life) discontinued New Balance 1123, in size 5 ½ 4E. It allows me to put in a little extra height in the right and both feet fit snug and with circulation (we ask so little at this point, don’t we?). And they discontinued it for the 1540 that hurts my feet. Boooo!

He also found me a Cambrian casual sandle that fit the ExoSym and had good stability for a sandal (hello summer) and a gorgeous Drew Geneva dress shoe in taupe that is so very comfortable with soft leather uppers and a stiff sole for support. Extra Wide Shoes can order any size and even some shoes they don’t have in stock for you to try.

In the end it was hard to swallow the almost $375 for three pairs of shoes. That was, until I went home and cleared out all the shoes that don’t fit any longer or hurt my feet. For years I spent $30-$50 a pop on New Balance shoes that felt amazing, for about two months. They didn’t have the stability, so they broke down for me once they were broken in. And they hardly look worn.

This here represents $1,000 wasted on shoes. Suddenly, $375 for shoes sounds very reasonable. With the right last, they’ll last.

PileOshoes
This is $1,000 of shoes, all of which don’t fit with the ExoSym or they hurt my feet. Luckily, many can go to my kids for them to grow into while the rest get donated.

So, the moral of my story is, do your research, visit Wide Shoes Only when in Washington for your ExoSyms (seriously, make this a requirement because no one I’ve met, not even the mighty Ryan, knows shoes like Dominic), and understand that one person’s perfect shoe may not be perfect for you. You can only try them on to know, and it’s best to try them on with someone who understands your condition and knows shoes. Like Dominic!

And on a final note, I’ve started a page here on Going Bionic dedicated to shoes and shoe tips, so as I learn things from trial and error, advice or tips from others, we can all find them in one place. May the odds be ever in your favor as you hunt for your perfect shoes.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “UPDATED: The Mighty Shoe Dilemma

  1. Sharon Larson

    So interesting Jen. There used to be a shoe guy on Mercer Island with the same kind of shoe smarts but I met him probably 25 years ago and he was ready to retire then. Glad you found this valuable resource. And wonderful that the Internet allows wide sharing!!

    Like

    1. It’s getting harder and harder to find these shoe folks. Thank goodness there are a number of manufacturers who see the value in designing for folks who need something more than the average shoe.

      Like

  2. ellenrosenthal

    Very interesting article. I hope I will be able to go to that store before too long.
    A small correction: The back part of your foot is the heel, not the heal. Maybe it was just a Freudian slip on your part 😉

    Like

  3. Thank you for writing such a wonderful article. You have inspired all of us at Wide Shoes Only to work harder and help people in need of finding that perfect shoes. I hope this new journey brings much happiness and good health.

    Like

  4. Pingback: The Good, Bad and the Ugly – 6 Months into the ExoSym – Adventures in Going Bionic

  5. Pingback: How to Extending Shoe Life – Adventures in Going Bionic

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s